At a glance
- A federal judge in Manhattan on 20 Nov denied the Commodity Futures Trading Commission’s renewed emergency request to stop New York from pursuing its gambling case against Kalshi, Reuters reported.
- The judge, Lorna Schofield, said the CFTC had “not established a likelihood of success on the merits” of its argument that federal law overrides state gambling laws for prediction markets, according to Reuters.
- New York has asked a state court for a restraining order against Kalshi. No ruling on that request had been reported as of 04:50 UTC on 21 Nov.
What the court did
The CFTC filed the emergency motion on Friday in United States v. State of New York, the lawsuit the federal government brought against the state in April. It asked for a temporary restraining order, a short-term court order that freezes the situation until a fuller hearing.
The docket describes it as a renewal of a request first made in July. Its only exhibit is the proposed restraining order that New York filed in state court. Judge Schofield set a telephone conference for 5:00 pm New York time the same day.
The judge denied the request in that hearing, CoinDesk reported, citing a social media post by attorney Daniel Wallach. When we checked the docket at about 04:45 UTC on 21 Nov, it showed no written ruling yet.
Reuters reported that the judge noted three federal appeals courts have ruled that states can regulate Kalshi, while a fourth said New Jersey could not. The CFTC did not immediately respond to Reuters’ request for comment.
How the case got here
New York’s attorney general sued Kalshi in state court in July, alleging that it needed a state gaming licence for contracts on sports, elections and other events. The case moved to federal court. On 19 Nov, a federal judge sent it back to state court, a step called remand, Reuters reported.
The CFTC argued in Friday’s filing that the remand left “no practical barrier to New York moving full steam ahead” against Kalshi, according to Reuters. In the same filing, CoinDesk reported, the agency said a New York order would force Kalshi to stop operating altogether because the company is headquartered in the state.
Kalshi’s spokeswoman, Elisabeth Diana, said in a statement to CoinDesk: “We want to work with the governor and attorney general on a resolution that protects the interests of the 1.2 million New Yorkers who use Kalshi.” The New York attorney general’s office had not commented publicly on Friday’s ruling on its press page by about 04:50 UTC on 21 Nov.
What happens next
The state court has to decide New York’s request for a restraining order; no hearing date had been reported.
The CFTC has sued 12 states over their actions against prediction markets, Reuters reported, including Louisiana and Arkansas. The agency has also directed exchanges to stop geofencing states, and this week 44 attorneys general asked the CFTC to withdraw its swap proposal.
This is not legal advice.
This article is for information only and is not investment advice.
