At a glance
- Attorneys general for 43 states and the District of Columbia filed two comment letters with the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) on 18 Nov, opposing the two rules it issued on 9 Oct on event contracts and gambling.
- They ask the CFTC to withdraw its proposal to define sports event contracts as swaps, and call its interim rule on casino-style gambling “arbitrary and capricious”.
- They also argue the CFTC, which has one commissioner, Chairman Michael Selig, lacks a quorum to make rules.
What they filed
The first letter answers the CFTC’s proposal to expand the legal definition of a “swap” to cover event contracts, bet-like derivatives that pay out depending on whether something happens. A swap is a contract the CFTC regulates. The proposal names sports, politics, culture and weather events.
The letter is signed by Ohio, Kentucky, Maryland, Nevada, New Jersey, New York, Tennessee, Utah, 35 other states and the District of Columbia. It was dated 18 Nov, 30 days after the proposal appeared in the Federal Register, the length of the comment period. “The CFTC should withdraw the Proposed Rule,” it says.
The second letter responds to the CFTC’s interim final rule, a rule that takes effect before public comment. That rule says casino-style gambling, where players bet against the house, is not a swap. Maryland’s attorney general, Anthony Brown, co-led both filings, his office said on 19 Nov.
The arguments
On the proposal, the states argue the Commodity Exchange Act does not make sports bets swaps. They cite rulings by the Sixth and Ninth Circuit appeals courts that the CFTC’s powers do not reach sports gambling. They say the CFTC has made “a 180-degree turn” from its past position that it “is not a gaming regulator”.
In a footnote, the letter says several signers also object to contracts on politics, elections, weather and culture.
On the interim rule, the states say “gambling has never been limited to house-backed games”. If state-regulated betting can be a swap, they argue, the rule would make pool-style betting such as horse racing a crime when it is offered outside a CFTC-registered exchange.
On the quorum point, the letter says the statute refers to “the remaining Commissioners” in the plural, so one commissioner cannot act as “the Commission”. It says a rule finalised without a quorum would be unlawful. That argument has not been tested in court.
What happens next
The CFTC has to consider public comments before it can finalise the proposal; it has not said when it will. The interim rule is already in effect.
The letters add to the agency’s disputes with states over prediction markets, including its lawsuit against Louisiana and the case in which the CFTC and the Justice Department sued Arkansas. In Congress, the Senate this week passed the DEATH BETS Act, which would ban contracts on war and death.
This is not legal advice.
Related: A federal judge has since refused the CFTC's emergency bid to stop New York's case against Kalshi
This article is for information only and is not investment advice.
