UPDATED 21:00 UTC, 19 Nov: Proposal 401 passed when voting ended at 18:46 UTC on 19 Nov, according to the dYdX chain’s governance record: about 185.9 million DYDX voted yes, 21.3 million abstained and fewer than 15 DYDX voted no. Under its terms, Noble deposits reopen and a delayed message switches them off again after 133,000 blocks, about 24 hours.
dYdX holders are voting on a proposal to reopen USDC deposits from the Noble blockchain for about 24 hours. The aim is to release $61,486 in USDC that bounced back into 13 Noble addresses after dYdX’s switch to Injective, addresses that no one holds a key to.
The money came from deposits made through so-called forwarding addresses. A forwarding address is an account on Noble that has no private key and does one job: it sends any USDC it receives on to one fixed dYdX address.
dYdX Chain’s v9.9 upgrade took effect at block 114,220,000, at 15:24 UTC (16:24 CET) on 17 Nov. From then on the chain rejected USDC transfers arriving from Noble, as it was designed to do.
dYdX’s 12 Nov migration post said deposits from Noble, “including CCTP transfers routed through Noble and Noble auto-forwarding addresses”, would be “rejected and refunded to the sending address on Noble”. For an auto-forwarding deposit, the sending address is the keyless forwarding account. That is where the refunds landed.
By Crypto Watch Desk’s own on-chain calculation, 14 deposits from 13 forwarding addresses were rejected between 16:04 and 23:19 UTC on 17 Nov, worth 76,486.28 USDC in total. One address was bounced twice: a 14,999.98 USDC deposit, then 15,019.95 USDC, which was the refund plus about $20 of new money.
Counted once, that leaves about 61,486.31 USDC stranded. Noble’s records show the same sum sitting on the 13 addresses this morning, in line with the $61,486.30 cited in the proposal.
The largest balance is 40,001.98 USDC, from a single deposit at 16:23 UTC on 17 Nov. The next two hold 15,019.95 and 1,999.98 USDC. Noble lists each of the 13 as a forwarding account with no public key and no fallback address.
At 09:04 UTC on 18 Nov, about 87.5 million DYDX had voted yes, and none had voted no, no-with-veto or abstain, the chain’s governance data show. That is a turnout of about 28.0% of the 312.9 million DYDX staked. As an expedited proposal, it needs at least half of staked DYDX to vote and 75% of votes cast to be yes.
Why it matters: the switch was forced on dYdX by Circle, which stopped new USDC minting on Noble and plans to pause USDC on Noble entirely on 12 Jan 2027. dYdX’s integrator guide told apps to repoint or stop forwarding addresses before the upgrade. The bounced deposits show not every route was switched off in time.
A vote with its own off switch
Proposal 401, “Reopen Noble USDC deposits and schedule re-close”, carries two instructions. The first turns Noble deposits back on. The second is a delayed message that turns them off again after 133,000 blocks, about 24 hours at the chain’s current pace of roughly 0.66 seconds a block.
The proposal was posted by forum user “eguegu”, whose forum profile reads “CLC Validator / dYdX Trading Arena”. We have not established the proposer’s affiliation.
In the forum post behind the vote, the proposer says the funds “cannot be recovered by the users, Noble, or any third party, because the forwarding addresses are keyless and can only send to dYdX”. Reopening deposits is “the only way to release these funds”, the post says.
The proposer also says the stranding stopped at block 114,264,200, “when Skip disabled Noble deposit routing”. Skip runs a cross-chain routing service used by wallets and apps. Our data show no new forwarding-address deposits after 23:19 UTC on 17 Nov, when that block was made.
The proposal does not say how the funds will move once deposits reopen. On our reading of how forwarding accounts work, each balance would have to be sent on to dYdX again during the window.
We covered dYdX’s Proposal 400 vote and the v9.9 upgrade in Chain Check. We have not tried to identify who owns the stranded funds, and Crypto Watch Desk did not ask dYdX for comment for this story.
DYDX traded at $0.0820 as of 09:04 UTC, according to Kraken. Voting on Proposal 401 closes on 19 Nov at 18:46 UTC (19:46 CET).
This article is for information only and is not investment advice.
