SECURITY ALERT

The first count was $4.86 million.

The second count is more than twice that.

Chainflip, the cross-chain swap protocol that halted on Saturday, says the attacker took 122.86 BTC from its vaults as well as 520.2 ETH, about 3.25 million USDC and about 758,000 USDT, according to a message it published on Saturday evening.

At bitcoin’s price when the coins moved, that comes to about $12 million in total, by CryptoWatchDesk’s arithmetic.

Chainflip has offered the attacker 10% of the funds as a bounty if the other 90% is returned by 18:38 UTC on 23 November.

So where is the bitcoin now?

The bitcoin leg

Our read of the Bitcoin record shows 122.86 BTC arriving at a single address at 07:01 UTC on Saturday, about nine minutes before the Ethereum vault was emptied in Saturday morning’s drain.

Bitcoin traded near $58,000 on Kraken at the time, which puts that leg at about $7.1 million.

As of 20:50 UTC the coins had not moved.

At 19:22 UTC Chainflip said on X that it had sent an on-chain message to the address holding the bitcoin. The Bitcoin record shows that message confirmed at 20:12 UTC, with the text: “Chainflip: return 90%, keep 10%. Addresses and terms: chainflip.io/return”.

The addresses, as read on Bitcoin:

Address holding the BTC: bc1qm777twlzmelyutungyfw65ykn2l5kn68e6v4g6

Transfer in (122.86 BTC): ac38a5aea1ed81b84307a3709f502abd4c4d3af5502493f883c6d19624fd2cb4

Chainflip’s message: 0f75dbd50f247d4d29ffb5d19dae9907f0322f9ef504720b7e27d2453624f004

The ether, by contrast, did not sit still. About 2,909 ETH went into Tornado Cash, a mixing service, within minutes of the drain, as we reported on Saturday afternoon.

What does Chainflip say it knows?

Chainflip’s account

Chainflip says it has traced how the attack was prepared: Tornado Cash funding on 11 November, a purchase of its FLIP token, and a validator account registered on 20 November, along with “the server behind it”.

Validators are the operators that jointly hold the key Chainflip’s vaults use to sign withdrawals. A validator registered a day before the drain is the closest Chainflip has come to explaining what happened.

“We have identified the mechanism of key exposure and have prevented such future attacks,” the message says. It does not describe that mechanism.

It also says the theft has been reported to law enforcement, that the attacker’s addresses are flagged with “the major blockchain analytics firms”, and that “every Tornado Cash withdrawal is being watched”. Those are Chainflip’s claims. No authority has commented publicly.

What is on the table?

The offer

Chainflip asks for 110.575 BTC and 2,618.1 ETH, 90% of each, to be sent to two return addresses it has published. If both arrive by the deadline, it says it will treat the incident as a white-hat recovery, “ask no further questions” and withdraw its reports to law enforcement.

Chainflip has not said when swaps, deposits and withdrawals will resume.

Its FLIP token traded at about $0.389 at 20:51 UTC, down about 18% over 24 hours, according to CoinGecko.

The ether here went through a mixer within eight minutes, the same mixer the Drift exploiter has used. The bitcoin has not been touched.

Will the bitcoin move before Monday’s deadline?

Protect yourself

  • Chainflip is still in safe mode. Do not send funds to a Chainflip deposit address, or through a wallet swap that routes via Chainflip, until Chainflip says otherwise on its official X account.
  • The return addresses on Chainflip’s page are for the attacker. Do not send anything to them.
  • Expect fake “refund” and “recovery” offers. Chainflip has not asked users to sign or claim anything. Read what a private key controls.

Corrections and new evidence: [email protected]

This article is for information only and is not investment advice.