SECURITY ALERT · UPDATE 1

Nobody broke in.

The keys were sitting in public, Lighter says.

Lighter, the perpetual-futures exchange that froze withdrawals on Monday morning, said at 18:21 UTC that deposits and withdrawals are “back to normal” after its Security Council switched off Guardian mode, a protective pause built into its smart contract.

In a post-mortem published a minute earlier, Lighter said the Guardian pause “allowed ~5MM USDC to be returned to the affected trader”. Pending withdrawals are being processed, it said.

That is the follow-up to our first report on the Lighter withdrawal pause, when Bubblemaps counted about $10.4 million in USDC taken out.

So how did the keys leak?

The nonce problem

Every trade on Lighter is signed with an API key. Each signature uses a nonce, a one-off random number that must never repeat.

Lighter says the affected accounts signed with code other than its official software kits, and that this code reused nonces.

Signatures on Lighter were public. If the same nonce signs two different messages with the same key, anyone can work out the private key from the pair, Lighter wrote. The same is true of bitcoin and ether signatures.

The attacker “needed no access to the accounts or to Lighter’s systems”, the post says.

Lighter says its official kits in Python, Go and TypeScript, and its Agent Kit, generate nonces safely and were not affected.

If the key could not send money to a stranger, how did the money leave?

The pool route

An API key can move funds to the account’s own sub-accounts, and a public pool the account creates counts as one, Lighter says. The attacker used the leaked key to create a public pool from the victim’s account.

The attacker then bought pool shares from a separate account.

Next, the victim’s funds went into the pool. That raised the pool’s value without minting new shares, so the attacker’s shares were suddenly worth almost everything in it.

The attacker redeemed and withdrew.

Lighter says a wallet signature is now required to move funds into a public pool, and that API key signatures are no longer public.

It plans IP allowlists, per-key limits and permissions, and monitoring for reused nonces, with affected keys voided.

What did the pause actually save?

What is still unclear

Lighter has not published a loss figure of its own.

It has not said whether the $5 million came out of the $10.4 million that Bubblemaps saw leave, or from the “additional withdrawal attempt by the attacker” it flagged at 12:49 UTC.

One reading means about half the money is back. The other means the theft was larger than first counted.

Some posts on X put the total across two market-maker accounts at about $15.5 million. We have not verified that.

Lighter has not named the trader. Protos reported one analyst’s claim linking an affected account to a large trading firm. Neither Lighter nor that firm has confirmed it, so we are not naming it.

On-chain, the main wallet Lighter named held 3,404.40 ETH when we read it at 20:52 UTC. That is about $6.2 million at Kraken’s ether price, by our arithmetic, and almost unchanged from 3,404.55 ETH at 14:42 UTC.

Main wallet (named by Lighter): 0xb3fffca23d4444eE73349825ACD84f7b5020e387

The money already swapped into wrapped Monero on Hyperliquid is a different matter. That trail mostly ends.

If the vault was never touched, whose code fails next?

Protect yourself

  • If you trade on Lighter with your own or a third-party bot, rotate every API key now and switch to an official Lighter SDK, as Lighter advises.
  • Never derive a signing nonce from a timestamp, a counter or the message itself. Use a cryptographically secure random generator for each signature.
  • Treat a trading key like a private key. Give it the narrowest permissions and revoke what you do not use, as SignalPlus did with its exchange keys.
  • Ignore direct messages offering refunds or “recovery” for Lighter losses. Lighter’s own channels are the only place to check.

Corrections and new evidence: [email protected]

This article is for information only and is not investment advice.