SECURITY ALERT
No one voted for it.
It is still pending.
A 15-transaction proposal with no Snapshot vote behind it is pending on the legacy Ethereum Safe of GnosisDAO, which holds about $1.29 million in tokens and is the registered owner of the gnosis.eth name, on-chain records show.
Whether it can ever run depends on a bond contest on Reality.eth, an on-chain question-and-answer oracle.
The current answer is “No”, backed by 400 GNO, about $39,852. It becomes final at 13:32 UTC (14:32 CET) on Friday 20 Nov unless someone answers with 800 GNO, about $79,704, with GNO at $99.63 as of 08:43 UTC on CoinGecko.
What was submitted
The legacy Safe can be moved in two ways: by three of its signers, or by its Reality module, which the DAO uses to carry out Snapshot votes. It is the only module switched on.
At 07:00:59 UTC (08:00 CET) on 17 Nov, an address submitted a bundle of 15 transaction hashes to that module.
The bundle’s id is “gnosis-dao-old-treasury-full-sweep-i3081”. “Full sweep” is the proposal’s own label.
Snapshot has no proposal with that id. A lookup on Snapshot’s hub returns nothing.
Only hashes went on-chain. The 15 transactions themselves have not been published, so what they would do cannot be read from the record.
Twenty-four seconds later, the same address answered “Yes” on the Reality.eth question for its own proposal, with a 100 GNO bond.
So who decides whether a proposal with no vote passed?
How the bonds decide it
On Reality.eth, anyone can answer, and each new answer must at least double the last bond. On this question, if nobody answers for 48 hours, the last answer stands.
The module would execute only on a final “Yes”, then after a 48-hour cooldown, inside a seven-day window, its on-chain settings show. The minimum bond is 100 GNO.
The record so far, in UTC:
- 17 Nov, 07:00. The bundle is submitted.
- 17 Nov, 07:01. “Yes”, 100 GNO, from the submitting address (tx).
- 17 Nov, 07:54. “Invalid”, 200 GNO, from a second address (tx).
- 17 Nov, 13:17. GnosisDAO’s own sweep vote, GIP-157, opens on Snapshot.
- 18 Nov, 13:32. “No”, 400 GNO, from a third address (tx).
- 20 Nov, 13:32. “No” becomes final if nobody answers.
At 08:43 UTC on 19 Nov (Ethereum block 26,448,005), the question still showed “No” at 400 GNO, not finalised, with no arbitration requested.
The DAO’s rules point one way. The gnosis.eth ENS name carries a “daorequirements” record, which links to a GnosisDAO acceptance-criteria document. It says the answer should be “yes” only for proposals that “were initiated as a Snapshot proposal in the gnosis.eth Snapshot space”, among seven conditions. “In all other cases, the Reality.eth question should be resolved to ‘no’,” it says.
The “No” answer was explained on the Gnosis forum early on 19 Nov by an account called “legacy-safe-watch”, which cites the same document. It discloses that it holds the 400 GNO “No” bond and gains 292.5 GNO if that answer stands. We checked the on-chain facts independently of the post.
What happens if the bonds and the rules disagree?
The referee is another oracle
A Reality.eth question can name an arbitrator, a party that can be paid to settle a dispute instead of the bonds.
This module names 0x5b7dD1E8…. Blockscout lists it as a verified RealityETH_v3_0 contract: another copy of the oracle, not a dispute service.
Our reading is that no one can buy a ruling in practice, so the larger bond decides. That is an inference from the contract type. The forum poster says the same, and suggests the DAO name a dispute service and lower the minimum bond. We have not tested an arbitration request.
The cost of a correction doubles each round: 800 GNO for the next answer, then 1,600 GNO, about $159,408, to reply to that.
If one side is willing to outspend the other, what stops it?
It is not GIP-157
GnosisDAO does want to empty this Safe. GIP-157, posted on the forum on 27 Oct, would move its assets to the DAO’s treasury Safe in 10 transactions. Its vote opened on Snapshot about six hours after the bundle was submitted, and closes at 13:17 UTC on 24 Nov. At 08:43 UTC it stood at about 1,357 for and 7.6 against in voting power, from 5 addresses.
We rebuilt the module’s transaction hashes for all 10 GIP-157 calls. All 10 match the hashes in the forum post.
None of the 15 hashes in the pending bundle matches any of them.
One entry, the second in the bundle, is what GIP-157’s first call would hash to at that position: a conversion of vCOW into COW that sends nothing to anyone. The token transfers match neither GIP-157’s transfers to the treasury Safe nor the same transfers re-pointed to the submitting address, at any position.
So the bundle’s transfers go to some other address, or move different amounts. Which, we cannot tell.
This is our own calculation. Only hashes are on-chain.
What the Safe holds, at 08:43 UTC prices:
| Asset | Amount | Value (USD) |
|---|---|---|
| COW, incl. vCOW convertible 1:1 | 13,387,478.77 | $1,246,254 |
| LDO, unclaimed rewards | 128,206.65 | $34,539 |
| stkAAVE, unclaimed rewards | 50.17 | $5,505 |
| BAL | 28,634.90 | $3,279 |
| ETH and WETH | 0.69 | $1,248 |
| LUSD | 259.29 | $259 |
| Total | $1,291,084 |
Almost all of the value is COW tokens; the two reward lines are claimable rather than held. Source: Ethereum on-chain balances, GIP-157 forum post (unclaimed rewards), CoinGecko prices, CryptoWatchDesk analysis. Excludes 728.73 1INCH.
GIP-157 put the total at about $1.7 million when it was posted on 27 Oct.
The Safe is also the registrant of gnosis.eth, gnosischain.eth, gnosisvpn.eth and omen.eth, according to the ENS registrar contract. Day-to-day control of the last three sits with other addresses.
We have not identified who controls the submitting address, and we make no claim about its purpose. Crypto Watch Desk did not ask GnosisDAO or the forum poster for comment for this story.
If the vote and the bundle both reach the module, which answer will the bonds back?
Evidence ledger
Legacy Safe: 0x0DA0C3e52C977Ed3cBc641fF02DD271c3ED55aFe
Reality module: 0x0d70332CEB7F3C94b061cda48327891E3449A9E1
Submitting address: 0x643a045e2c44430bf4d0115fead3ad38ba1b8f78
Proposal tx (block 26,433,136): 0x5a6f4cbab427fb2d835f0e7c5675375f42314fe9eb6b343ee13508d7fc479727
Reality.eth question (GNO-bonded instance 0x33aa365a…): 0xd1ddad5c527b33cbd632037083b0b9bec454cb0833531d241a09da19c625fdd8
Module arbitrator (RealityETH_v3_0): 0x5b7dd1e86623548af054a4985f7fc8ccbb554e2c
Protect yourself
- GNO holders: the vote that counts is GIP-157 on the gnosis.eth Snapshot space. It closes on 24 Nov at 13:17 UTC.
- Anyone following the question: check it on Reality.eth before 13:32 UTC on Friday. A new answer needs at least 800 GNO and restarts the 48-hour clock.
- DAOs using a Reality module: check which arbitrator it names and how high the minimum bond is. Watch it for questions no one on your team asked.
- A Reality.eth bond can be lost in full. The forum post makes the same warning.
One proposal, no vote. One question, three answers.
When the referee is just another oracle, is the biggest bond the DAO’s real governance?
Corrections and new evidence: [email protected]
Related: the Gnosis Pay card-data alert · ENS DAO’s vote on writing ETH options from its endowment · ENSv2 and the freeze of v1 .eth registrations
This article is for information only and is not investment advice.
