At a glance
- US District Judge Jessica G. L. Clarke granted Anton and James Peraire-Bueno’s motion for a judgment of acquittal on Monday 16 Nov, according to the court docket in Manhattan federal court (case 1:24-cr-00293).
- The order says the evidence failed to show the brothers made “any material misrepresentations” in the April 2023 trade that prosecutors said took about $25 million from automated trading bots on Ethereum. It directs the clerk to close the case.
A judgment of acquittal is a ruling by the judge, not a jury, that the evidence cannot support a conviction. The brothers’ first trial, in October 2025, ended in a mistrial in November that year after the jury deadlocked, The Block reported.
They were acquitted of wire fraud, conspiracy to commit wire fraud and conspiracy to commit money laundering, TokenPost reported. A fourth charge, receiving stolen property, was dismissed in July 2025.
What the court said
The docket entry for the order frames the question narrowly. “This case is not about whether the Peraire-Buenos conduct ‘was improper, objectionable, or even despicable,'” it says, quoting an earlier appeals ruling.
The narrower test, the order says, is whether the brothers committed wire fraud and the related charged crimes. Wire fraud requires a material misrepresentation, a false statement that matters to the victim’s decision. The judge found none in the execution of “Omakase”, the name the case gives the strategy.
The Block reported that the judge also noted the trades did not take place on a regulated market where such conduct would be prohibited. The full opinion was not yet public on the free docket archive when we checked.
What prosecutors alleged
The brothers were arrested in May 2024. Prosecutors said they exploited a weakness in MEV-Boost, relay software that passes bundles of transactions to Ethereum validators, and reordered other traders’ transactions in about 12 seconds.
MEV, or maximal extractable value, is the profit available from choosing the order of transactions in a block. The targets were “sandwich” bots, which profit by trading just before and after other users. In The Block’s account of the case, bait transactions drew the bots in.
What supporters say
Peter Van Valkenburgh, executive director of Coin Center, a crypto policy group, called it “excellent news”. Coin Center had filed a friend-of-the-court brief arguing that “honest” validation has a specific technical meaning on Ethereum, against the prosecutors’ theory.
We found no statement from the US Attorney’s Office for the Southern District of New York on its X account by 20:56 UTC.
What happens next
The order closes the case on the docket. Prosecutors have not said publicly whether they will try to challenge it, and we are not guessing. The written opinion should explain the reasoning in full once it is available.
For the Justice Department’s other crypto cases this month, see its move to seize $1.2 billion from the Binance hack and Block’s $764 million deal over Cash App.
This article is for information only and is not investment advice.
