Cardano’s token holders have rejected a request to spend 22 million ADA from the network’s treasury on physical copper. The proposal expired on Sunday 15 Nov at 21:44 UTC without the votes it needed, according to Cardanoscan, and no ADA leaves the treasury.

Cardano is a so-called proof-of-stake blockchain, a network where holders lock up tokens to help run it. Holders also vote on how its treasury is spent, mostly through delegated representatives, or DReps, whom they choose to cast their voting power for them.

Toto Finance, a company that issues blockchain tokens backed by commodities, had asked for the 22 million ADA in October. A treasury withdrawal needs yes votes from 67% of the voting stake that picked a side, and approval from a seven-member constitutional committee that checks spending against the chain’s rules.

DReps cast about 20 million ADA for the plan, or 0.51%, and about 2.86 billion ADA against it, according to Cardanoscan and CoinDesk. A further 131 million ADA sat with an “always no confidence” option. Five DReps voted yes and 126 no, Cardanoscan shows.

None of the committee’s members voted yes. Three judged it unconstitutional and four had not voted by the deadline, CoinDesk and Cardanoscan report.

What Toto proposed

About two-thirds of the money, 14.72 million ADA, would have bought COMEX-grade copper stored near New Orleans, according to crypto.news. The metal would have been tokenized at one token per pound and held for 18 to 24 months, then sold, with proceeds returned to the treasury within 36 months.

CoinDesk reported that copper would have needed to rise about 49% for the treasury to get its ADA back if ADA’s dollar price stayed flat, and that Toto could have collected up to about 3.36 million ADA in fees. Founder Monty Metzger told CoinDesk in October that “Toto takes no profit from this proposal”.

CoinDesk put the request at about $5 million. At ADA’s price of about $0.152 on Monday, by our arithmetic, 22 million ADA is about $3.3 million.

Why it matters

Treasury money is limited. Holders have capped withdrawals at 500 million ADA through about July 2027, and 457.4 million of that was already committed as of 16 Oct, CoinDesk said. That left about 42.6 million, so the copper request alone would have used more than half of it.

It was a rare test of whether a network would put communal money into real-world commodities. The answer, for now, is no. Our Chain Check of 17 Oct flagged that the budget was close to its cap. Tokenization elsewhere is moving through banks and market utilities, as in DTCC’s plan for Solana.

What is still open

Two other treasury withdrawals, AURORA and PFMS, were due to expire on 20 Nov, according to Intersect’s weekly update, with data as of 13 Nov. We have not checked their latest votes.

ADA traded at about $0.152 at 10:50 UTC on Monday, down about 1.4% in 24 hours, according to CoinGecko.

Related: Next vote: the Cardano Foundation has asked the treasury for 25 million ADA for 12 conferences in 2027

This article is for information only and is not investment advice.